Where To Eat: Best Restaurants in Modica, Sicily

Here are 10 of the best restaurants in Modica, Sicily in Italy.

Best Restaurants in Modica Sicily featured photo

In a country known to have one of the best loved cuisines in the world, eating good food comes second nature. The Italian city of Modica is no exception to this. Aside from its astonishing Baroque architecture, narrow ancient streets, and friendly locals, visitors of Modica also can’t get enough of its delicious food.

Whether you’re looking for an upscale ristorante, a relaxing wine bar, or a casual place that serves good street food, we’ve got you covered! In this article, we’ll share with you our top 10 picks of the best places to eat in this lovely Sicilian city. 

modica, sicily at night with dramatic lighting

Michelin-Starred Restaurants

Michelin-Starred Restaurants in Modica Sicily

If you’re a foodie, chances are you already know how special a Michelin star is. For those unfamiliar, having a Michelin star is perhaps the highest culinary recognition a chef or a restaurant can receive. And Modica has three Michelin-starred restaurants – it’s a super impressive feat for a relatively small town.

1. Accursio Ristorante: An Excellent Restaurant

Accursio Ristorante Kitchen in Modica SicilyAccursio Ristorante Food in Modica Sicily

The first Michelin-starred restaurant on our list is Accursio Ristorante. It is a cutting-edge contemporary restaurant that serves creative and original recipes by one of Sicily’s most prominent chefs, Accursio Craparo. As one can expect from a Michelin-starred ristorante, Accursio offers extremely high-quality cooking and presentation. 

Enjoy European dishes in an intimate, lovely setting furnished with only a few tables, beautiful tiles, and images of traditional Sicilian rural life.

Location: Via Clemente Grimaldi 41, Modica, Sicily, Italy | Website

2. La Locanda del Colonnello 

La Locanda del Colonnello in Modica Sicily

Next on our list is another Michelin-starred restaurant located in the quaint area of Modica Alta. La Locanda del Colonnello is the onsite restaurant of the elegant Hotel Palazzo Failla. It serves Sicilian dishes but with a twist. This excellent trattoria offers a more casual service compared to a ristorante that is usually much formal.

Note: La Locanda Is temporarily closed and will resume operations on March 22, 2022.

Location: Via Blandini 9, Modica, Sicily, Italy | Website

3. Fattoria delle Torri

Fattoria delle Torri in Modica Sicily

Our final Michelin-starred restaurant is Fattoria delle Torre. It’s a comfortable restaurant that serves innovative yet traditional Italian dishes. Owned by celebrated chef Peppe Barone, the restaurant is now managed by his daughters, Francesca and Carla, who take on an excellent modern twist to traditional Sicilian recipes. 

Location: Vico Napolitano 14, Vicino Piazza Matteotti, Modica, Sicily, Italy | Website

Other Favorite Modica Restaurants

Most of us can’t afford to eat at Michelin-level spots every single night, plus casual trattoria food executed well is always a favorite of mine. Unless I’m in the mood for something fancy, I prefer an atmosphere a bit more laid back on a typical night.

4. Rappa Enoteca: Best Wine Bar

Rappa Enoteca Wine Bar in Modica Sicily

Rappa Enoteca is a highly rated restaurant and wine bar at the top of Modica. It serves casual Southern Italian cuisine and is known for its excellent selection of Sicilian vintage wines. The owner and friendly staff are very knowledgeable about their wines, too.

Location: Corso Santa Teresa 97/99, Modica, Sicily, Italy | Website

5. Singola Organic Restaurant: Best for Vegan 

Singola Organic Restaurant Vegan Food

If you’re looking for something that serves healthy Mediterranean food, then head to Singola Organic Restaurant. This place is known for its superb vegetarian and organic Sicilian dishes. Even if you’re not a vegan or vegetarian, you’ll enjoy the home-cooked dishes here. The service is also commendable — prompt and professional.

Location: Via Risorgimento 88, Modica, Sicily, Italy

6. I Lupini: Best Street Food 

Trying the street food of the place you are visiting is the best way to try its local cuisine. Sink your teeth into Modica’s local flavor at I Lupini. This restaurant is known to serve fresh Italian seafood dishes at reasonable prices. It’s also the place to go to if you want the best street food. 

Location: Via Santa 22 Adiacente a piazza Matteotti, 97015, Modica, Sicily Italy | Website

7. Ornato Ristorante di Pesce: Best Seafood Dishes

Ornato Ristorante di Pesce is a treat for both the eyes and the palate. This nicely decorated seafood and fish restaurant serves traditional Sicilian recipes made from fresh and healthy local ingredients. 

Location: Via Pozzo Barone 30 Parcheggiare in via Vittorio Veneto e salire le scale dietro il rifornimento di benzina., Modica, Sicily, Italy

8. Osteria dei Sapori Perduti 

Osteria dei Sapori Perduti in Modica Sicily

An osteria was a place that’s way less formal than a ristorante or a trattoria and usually only served wine. Guests can bring their own food and order only wine. It was like an Italian tavern where customers come to get cheap drinks. However, over the years, osterias also started to serve simple food along with their wines. 

Osteria dei Sapori Perduti retains the casual atmosphere of the traditional wine bar while serving some of the best homemade Italian dishes in Modica. The restaurant’s must-tries are their meatballs and their ravioli. 

Location: Corso Umberto I 228, 97015, Modica, Sicily, Italy | Website

Dessert in Modica

9. Antica Dolceria Bonajuto

Antica Dolceria Bonajuto in Modica Sicily

In case you didn’t know yet, Modica is also well known for its wonderful chocolates. Located in front of Duomo di San Pietro, Antica Dolceria Bonajuto is the oldest chocolate shop in all of Sicily and can be quite busy at times as a result. The customers love their pastries, cakes, and of course the chocolates! You can also join their chocolate tour and take a peek at their bean-to-bar chocolate laboratory which is a great daytime activity. 

Location: Corso Umberto I 228, Modica, Sicily, Italy | Website

cocoa powder and chocolate bars in Modica, Sicily

10. Caffé Adamo

Caffé Adamo Smoothies in Modica SicilyCaffé Adamo Gelato in Modica Sicily

There’s no better way to end your food trip in Modica than to finish it with sweet treats. Caffé Adamo serves mouthwatering gelatos, cremoletas, and other Sicilian sweets. They also offer fresh pastries, great coffee, and a good wine list. This cafe is managed by artisanal ice cream maker Antonio Adamo and was named by Dissapore as one of the best 100 ice cream parlors in Italy.

Location: Via Marchesa Tedeschi 17, 97015, Modica, Sicily Italy | Website 

​​Caffé Adamo in Modica Sicily

Where to Stay in Modica

Modica is such a beautiful city, definitely worth spending a few nights at minimum. Since we really like this town, we also made a list of the best hotels in Modica to help you plan your trip more quickly. Be sure to check it out! Hot tip: Modica is almost all hillsides, so make sure to factor in location within the city if you want to limit your climbing.